Not every landlord is looking for the same thing, and credit scores aren’t always the dealbreaker people think they are.
Renting often feels like a numbers game, where your credit score is the deciding factor. But what if you don’t have good credit, or any credit at all?
We’ve been taught that a low credit score can block access to just about everything, from housing to loans. But when it comes to renting, that assumption doesn’t always hold up.
Credit scores aren’t a pass/fail test. They’re just one piece of a broader risk assessment. If you’re using tools like Borrowell or Credit Karma, it’s also worth knowing how accurate those scores are in the first place.
Improve your credit score with a Neo Secured Mastercard! Plus, sign up now via the button below and get a $60 welcome bonus.
* Limited-time offer. Only valid for new Neo customers who open their first eligible Neo credit product and make a purchase within 90 days.
In a tight rental market, many landlords are less focused on a single number and more concerned with whether rent will be paid consistently.
To get a clearer picture, I reached out to 20 landlords and rental listings across the GTA through platforms like Facebook Marketplace, ViewIt, Kijiji, and Rentals.ca and asked them directly: do you require a credit check as part of the application process?
Of the landlords who clearly answered the question, 11 out of 20 said they required a credit check as part of the application process. That works out to 55%.
But the other 9 responses weren’t all a simple “no credit check required.” Some said they didn’t require one upfront, while others suggested there may be flexibility depending on the rest of the application. In those cases, strong income, references, employment stability, or a guarantor could help offset weaker or limited credit.
So, no credit check apartments do still exist, but they’re not always advertised that way. In many cases, it’s less about finding a landlord who never checks credit and more about finding one who is willing to look at the full picture.
Credit checks are often required, but it’s not a hard and fast rule.
Most landlords I spoke to said they do run credit checks as part of the application process, but several said they were still willing to consider applicants with strong income, references, or guarantors.
Some were straightforward: “Yes, I run a full credit report.” Others were more flexible: “I usually ask for it, but if everything else looks good, I can be flexible.”
This was especially true of independent landlords who aren’t bound by the same rigid screening processes.
Some landlords declined to answer directly over messaging or asked to discuss screening requirements by phone.
Jason Ferreira, an independent landlord with more than a decade of experience managing his own rental properties, explained it this way:
“Credit is helpful, but it’s just one piece. I’m trying to understand the full picture: income, job stability, how they communicate. The score alone doesn’t tell me everything.”
Even in more structured processes, there can be some wiggle room. One realtor described credit checks as an “absolute requirement,” but said applicants with weaker credit may still be considered if they can explain their situation and provide a guarantor.
In practice, it’s often case by case, making it harder for renters to know where they stand without going further into the application process.
Income and stability matter more than a single number
Landlords seem to care less about a perfect credit score and more about whether you can reliably pay rent.
“If someone has a solid, stable job, that’s usually the biggest factor,” one landlord said. Another put it more directly: “I care more about income and consistency than a perfect score.”
Jason echoed that perspective: “If someone is clearly earning enough and has been in their role for a while, that gives me more confidence than just seeing a number on a report.”
In practice, that means renters with steady employment, verifiable income, and solid references can still be competitive even without perfect credit.
That same pattern shows up in other areas of personal finance, too. Whether you’re renting or trying to qualify for something like a mortgage with bad credit history, lenders and landlords are usually looking at the full picture, not just a single number.
No credit is different from bad credit
One theme came up repeatedly: there’s a big difference between no credit and bad credit.
“No credit is easier to work with than bad credit,” one landlord told me. Another said late payments or collections are where things get tricky.
That distinction matters. No credit might raise questions, but bad credit can raise red flags.
Jason put it bluntly: “No credit just means I need more context. Bad credit usually tells a story, and not always a good one.”
What landlords actually look at
Here’s how the most common screening factors stacked up based on my conversations:
When credit checks matter more
While many landlords demonstrated some level of flexibility, that doesn’t apply everywhere.
Credit checks were more likely to be strictly required when:
- Applying to large property management companies
- Competing in high-demand rental markets
- Applying without strong income or references
In bigger buildings, it’s more standardized. You either meet the criteria or you don’t. In these cases, credit becomes less negotiable.
Why some landlords are getting stricter
While many landlords demonstrated some flexibility, others are becoming more cautious, especially in markets where demand is high and tenant protections are strong.
Jason told me credit checks have become a non-negotiable part of his process.
“I wouldn’t rent without a credit check. At the end of the day, you’re taking on a lot of risk as a landlord and it’s not easy to recover if something goes wrong.”
That risk isn’t theoretical.
“If a tenant stops paying, you still have to maintain the property, and it can take 12 to 15 months for a case to even be heard. That’s a long time to carry that cost.”
Because of that, Jason says his standards have shifted.
“These days, I wouldn’t go below a 700 credit score. There’s been a real uptick in fraud, so you have to be more cautious.”
Did any landlords skip credit checks entirely?
Of the landlords I spoke to, most said they do run credit checks, but a small number were open to skipping them depending on the situation.
These were typically independent landlords renting units directly, rather than larger property management companies. In those cases, factors like income, references, or upfront payment mattered more than a formal credit report.
So, can you rent without a credit check?
Yes, but it depends on how strong the rest of your application is.
Based on these responses, units rented directly by owners, rather than large management companies, were the most likely to offer flexibility around credit checks.
In a few cases, suggested they may be flexible around credit requirements depending on the situation. This was more common with private rentals listed on platforms like Facebook Marketplace and Kijiji.
You’re more likely to succeed without a credit check if you can show:
- Stable, sufficient income
- Consistent employment
- Strong references
You may also have better luck with:
- Independent landlords
- Smaller buildings
- Direct, one-on-one rental situations
As Jason Ferreira put it: “At the end of the day, I’m asking: do I trust this person to pay rent every month? Credit helps answer that, but it’s not the only way.”
That said, not every renter will be able to secure a lease right away, especially in competitive markets or without strong financials.
For renters who are struggling to get approved, short-term options may be worth considering while you strengthen your application. Some people turn to alternatives like cheap motels you can rent monthly, which can offer temporary flexibility without the same screening requirements.
